Paraphrased below is a certain sentiment that seems to make intuitive sense as a rebuttal in the context of a tone argument:
The problem is that it is only true if there wasn't a controversy to begin with.
( Let's take that analogy further... )
The fact that these people keep vociferously shouting that something is the case suggests that it is not, or at least it is not a natural fact that is independent of their assertion. After all, no one gets worked up over asserting that the laws of gravity apply.
The problem is that it is only true if there wasn't a controversy to begin with.
( Let's take that analogy further... )